Advertising Disclosure

Almay Eyeliner Pencil Review

Author image
By Best Choice team
Checked icon Last updated - July 23, 2025
8.8

Verdict overview

  • worth the money 8.4
  • Simple to use 9.1
  • Long life 8.9
Pros
  • Long-lasting color for all-day wear.
  • Gentle on sensitive eyes.
  • Built-in sharpener for easy use.
Cons
  • Tip may break easily.

Tech specs

product dimensions1.94 x 0.44 x 5.75 inches 0.01 ounces

Product Overview

I recently had the pleasure of trying out Almays Eyeliner Pencil in the color 205 Black. Im a big fan of Almay products and was excited to try this one out. I was not disappointed!

The pencil is easy to use with its built in sharpener that keeps the point sharp for precise definition. The formula is also oil free, water resistant, long lasting, and smudge proof so it wont run, smear, or rub off. Its also formulated with Vitamin E to nourish and protect your delicate eye area. On top of all that, its hypoallergenic, ophthalmologist tested, fragrance free, clean, and cruelty free. What more could you ask for?

I found that this eyeliner pencil lasted up to 16 hours without having to reapply it throughout the day. This was great as it made my morning routine much quicker! It was also very easy to use I simply traced my upper lash line and blended it in with a brush if necessary. The color was true to what it said on the package a nice black that wasnt too harsh looking.

The price tag on this product is slightly higher than some other eyeliner pencils but it is definitely worth it due to its longevity and quality ingredients.

Overall, I highly recommend Almays Eyeliner Pencil in 205 Black for those looking for an easy to use eyeliner that wont smudge or fade throughout the day. It has all the features you could want in an eyeliner pencil such as long lasting wearability and nourishing ingredients that will help keep your delicate eye area healthy and protected throughout the day.

Where to buy:

Can't decide which eyeliner to buy?

Compare the best eyeliners and choose the one that works for you

Compare eyeliner
Faq icon

Frequently asked questions

  • What type of eyeliner is this? Arrow icon
  • How long does the color last? Arrow icon
  • Is this product smudge proof? Arrow icon
  • What type of finish does it have? Arrow icon
  • Does this product contain any nourishing ingredients? Arrow icon

The secret behind our reviews

By Best Choice team

Best Choice Team is your go-to source for curated product recommendations across various categories. Leveraging years of industry experience and advanced AI technology, we analyze data from multiple sources to bring you the most relevant and up-to-date product lists.

Our AI-driven approach allows us to streamline the selection process, ensuring that the products we feature align with current market trends and consumer preferences. We aim to provide content that helps you navigate your purchasing decisions with greater ease Like.

Users reviews

88% of reviewers would recommend to a friend, Based on 10,944 Reviews

Show highlight comments

Leave a reply

You can help us improve our product reviews by providing us with your feedback. Please share your thoughts in the section below.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.